What we drank this weekend: Spanish wine tasting results

As many of you may have read, we helped host a wine tasting last weekend, of a selection of Spanish wines. We had planned on adding our own tasting notes to those by the Wine Advocate and the Wine Spectator. But we were so busy leading the event that we didn’t fully get to experience the wines in a way that would allow us to write up complete tasting notes.

As a consolation, we’re going to give you a wrap up of the favorites of the evening, and the group’s overall responses to the wines. Nobody was aware of the prices of the wines or their scores when tasting, and these were only revealed after the votes were counted. White wines were used as the arrival cocktails and only the red wines were part of the scoring at the end of the evening.

NB, we didn’t vote in the final tally, so this list does not take domaine547 preferences into account. Additionally, the scoring here was done by a system that is not completely scientific, but one which this wine-tasting group has been using for years…so we just went with it.

1st place: 2003 Rioja Vega Crianza, Proprietary Red Blend, Rioja, $13.99

This came away with the most votes for favorite wine of the evening, and people were stunned to learn that the wine scored a 78 from the Spectator. In fact, one person said that this would now become his go-to “everyday” wine, but freely admitted that if he’d know about the Spectator score, he would never have bothered to try, and certainly wouldn’t have paid money, for the wine.

Wine Advocate notes (89pts): The 2003 Crianza is medium ruby-colored with an expressive nose of cedar, cinnamon, red currants, and black raspberry. This is followed by a supple-textured, ripe, medium-bodied wine with no hard edges (atypical for a 2003 Rioja). Drink this nicely balanced, fruit-driven Rioja over the next 6 years.

Wine Spectator notes (78pts): Firm and a bit sharp, this red delivers cherry and smoke flavors with gamy and earthy notes. Tempranillo, Mazuelo and Graciano.

2nd place: 2005 Espelt “Saulo”, 60% Garnacha, 40% Carinera, Costa Brava (Emporda)

This was the second crowd pleaser of the bunch, with people noting its easy-to-drink fruit-forward style, very subdued tannins, and nice integration of the structure and fruit. When we showed off the synthetic cork closure, and revealed the cheap price-tag, the crowd seemed a little surprised, again admitting that if they knew any of these details it would have had an impact on whether or not they would have considered purchasing the wine.

Wine Advocate/Parker notes (87pts): Espelt Viticultors, an organically farmed estate, is located on the mountainous winding road leading to the world famous Catalunyan restaurant El Bulli. The red wine, the 2005 Saulo, is 50% Garnacha and 50% Carinena aged in barrel for 3-4 months. Dark ruby-colored, it offers smoky cherry aromas and flavors. Supple on the palate, with tasty flavors and no hard edges, this is an easy-drinking wine to accompany tapas and bistro cuisine.

3rd place: 2003 Ercavio “La Meseta” Shiraz/Tempranillo blend, La Mancha, $19.99

The group noted a raisin/currant element to the nose, along with some lilacs and cigar box. The spiciness of the wine along with the depth of fruit resonated, and the fact that there were no scores to validate or invalidate people’s opinions seemed to make everybody feel more confident with their own palates. Very interesting!

No published tasting notes that we could find.

4th place (tie): 2004 Vinas de la Vega Quinta Sardonia, Red blend, Castilla Leon, $60

Only two people voted for this wine, but both as their favorite. These happened to be the two people who seemed to have the most experience tasting wine, and could see through all the structure to what the wine will evolve into in the coming years. Others didn’t quite know what to make of the dusty tannins and earthy components. If this were a few years older, it would certainly have ranked closer to the top of the list.

Wine Advocate notes (96pts): This new project is co-owned by Peter Sisseck of Pingus fame and the vineyards are cultivated using biodynamic principles. The 2004 Quinta Sardonia is a blend of 36% Tinto Fino, 30% Cabernet Sauvignon, 20% Merlot, 5% Syrah, 5% Cabernet Franc, 3% Malbec,and 1% Petit Verdot. It is purple-colored with a sexy, kinky nose of spice box, smoke, creme de cassis, blueberry pie, rhubarb, and blackberry liqueur. Already complex on the palate, the wine is ripe and layered with gobs of spicy black fruits, beautifully integrated oak, tannin, and acidity, and a 45-second finish. It can be enjoyed now but should evolve for 4-6 years and drink well through 2027. Peter Sisseck hereby has demonstrated that he does not need old vines to achieve his magic.

4th place (tie) 2004 Bodegas Juan Gil, “Juan Gil”, 100% Monastrell, Jumilla, $14.99

While this went over very well, it was not number one for anybody. This was just that solid, middle-of-the-pack performer. A reliable wine, an enjoyable wine. It went over very well, but didn’t have that extra sumthin’ sumthin’ to push it to the top of anybody’s list. If we average the 90 parker gave it with the 84 from the Spectator, this becomes an 87 point wine…exactly how people perceived it.

Wine Advocate/Parker notes (90pts): A serious effort, the 2004 Juan Gil is fashioned from 45-year-old Mourvedre vines and is aged for 12 months in American and French oak. This rich, full-bodied, inky/purple-tinged cuvee exhibits aromas of scorched earth, blueberries, licorice, and pepper, a savory, layered texture, and remarkable opulence for a Mourvedre. Drink it over the next 3-4 years (2006 – 2010)

Wine Spectator notes (84pts): Oak dominates this thick red, with coffee and chocolate flavors and chewy tannins. Plum and raisin flavors are subdued, but they linger on the finish. Mourvèdre. Drink now through 2010

5th place: 2004 Cellar l’Encastell “Marge”, Garnacha, Syrah, Merlot, Cab blend), $24.99

Again, this went over well as an ‘easy drinking’ wine, but nobody claimed it as their favorite, and only one person, each, ranked the wine as either their second and third favorite wine of the evening. Our notes are a bit thin at this point, as it was getting late in the evening. Forgive us for not having a better explanation!

Wine Advocate notes for similarly constructed 2005 vintage (90pts): The 2005 Marge (named not after a female but rather the local name for the stone walls in the hillside vineyards of Priorat) is a blend of 60% Garnacha, 14% Syrah, 13% Merlot, and 13% Cabernet Sauvignon aged for 8 months in French and American oak. It reveals a lovely perfume of pepper, spice box, black cherry, and black currants. This is followed by a plush, ripe, full-flavored wine with nicely integrated oak, tannin, and acidity. Drink this tasty wine now and over the next 6-8 years.

6th place: 2003 Pasaijes IX, Tempranillo/Garnacha blend, Rioja

Two people claimed this as their 3rd favorite, and two others claimed it as their least favorite, canceling each other out. People could definitely taste the terroir in this, and were intrigued by the single vineyard aspect of the wine. Because vineyard designations aren’t allowed in the Rioja D.O. labeling rules, the winemakers assign a Roman numeral to refer to the specific plot of land from which the grapes for this wine originate. People tasted blueberries and dusty soil in this. For us, this is a stand-out wine with an incredible sense of place, but for the crowd this was more difficult to approach.

Wine Advocate notes on 2004 vintage (91pts): The 2004 Paisajes IX is composed of 50% Tempranillo and 50% Garnacha from 40- to 60-year-old vines planted in the village of Nalda. The wine was aged for 14 months in French oak. Inky in appearance, the wine offers up an unusual hint of mint as well as spice box, tobacco, black cherry and blackberry. The wine is supple on the palate with spicy black fruit flavors and excellent length. It should drink well now and over the next 8-10 years. Vila Viniteca is a joint venture between Miquel Angel de Gregorio of Finca Allende and Quim Vila, owner of Vila Viniteca, a fine wine shop in Barcelona. The objective, according to importer Eric Solomon, is to select special vineyard sites with old vines planted with unique/indigenous varietals. The wines are discussed in the order in which they were presented.

Last place: 2004 Anima Negra “AN/2” Callet, Mantonegro, Syrah blend, Balearas Islands (Majorca), $21.99

People didn’t know what to make of this wine. It is hands-down one of our favorites at domaine547, so we were extremely disappointed by the poor reception this wine garnered. Perhaps it had something to do with the wine being made of so many grape varietals not found in any of the other wines. This has flavors that border on Port-like without going over the edge in terms of alcohol or over-ripeness. We’re very, very sad that this didn’t receive standing ovations, and we still stand fully behind this wine. It’s just that against the Garnachas and Tempranillos, this was an oddball and one that seemed to throw the crowd off a bit.

Interestingly, the crowd this time agreed with the Spectator and not Parker (as with the Rioja Vega Crianza). So for the most and least favorite wines, the group allied themselves with different voices from the wine press. Which goes to show, there is only one palate to trust: your own.

Wine Advocate notes (91pts): The 2004 AN/2 is a blend of 65% Callet, 25% Mantonegro, and 10% Syrah. Subsequently, 85% of the wine was aged in French oak (70% new) and 15% in tank for a total of 10 months. Dark ruby-colored, with expressive toasty, smoky, kirsch and raspberry aromas and flavors, on the palate this medium to full-bodied wine is rich yet elegant, nicely layered, and has a long, pure finish. Drink this unique wine over the next 4-6 years.

Wine Spectator notes on 2003 vintage (79pts): Cherry candy, cedar and tobacco flavors jostle in this assertive red. It’s light-bodied, but the tannins are aggressive.

Disqualified (Corked): 2004 Tomas Cusine “El Vilosell” Tempranillo, Cab, Merlot, Garnacha and Syrah blend, Costers del Segre, Priorat, $13.99

What a bummer. Another wine we love, we opened this and immediately noticed something wrong with the cork. We tasted it and, sure enough, it was corked. We didn’t have a second bottle on hand so we weren’t able to include this in the tasting. This is a phenomenal wine and a terrific value, and we would have liked to see the group response since it was an anything but predictable group.

Wine Advocate notes for similar 2005 vintage (which will be coming in soon; 91pts): The 2005 El Vilosell is composed of 50% Tempranillo, 26% Cabernet Sauvignon, 10% Merlot, 9% Garnacha, and 5% Syrah aged for 9 months in new French oak. Purple-colored, it reveals a fragrant array of scents including pepper, spice box, smoke, blackberry, black currant, and blueberry pie. Plush in texture, the wine is full-bodied, with layers of spicy fruit, intense flavors, and well-concealed tannins. Drink this superb value now and over the next 6-8 years.

For prices on these wines, see our previous post. Or go to our store to buy these wines if any intrigue you.

what's all this, then?

Domaine 547 is a community meant for people who want to come along with us on our journey, as we learn about the world of wine.

It’s a point of view, that says wine need not be put on a pedestal or saved for special occasions, but should instead be a part of everyday life—because life is just that much better with a glass of wine in your hand (unless, of course, you are an alcoholic or under the age of 21).

Domaine 547 is a virtual tour guide, a way for all of us to travel the globe, even when our wallets and schedules might not permit physically doing so.

Mostly, it’s a place without pretensions, where we can drink, learn, communicate, and probably drink some more. And of course, there is no snobbery or attitude allowed.

Learn more about us…

The domaine547 name, logo, illustrated characters and all other materials on this site copyright © domaine547 unless otherwise noted. All rights reserved.

No site is complete without links for all the legal mumbo jumbo and privacy information.